Analysis of a Mal-operation of Differential Protection After the DC Resistance Testing

doi:10.11930/j.issn.1004-9649.2013.2.55.4

Abstract

Abstract: After the DC resistance testing of a transformer, the residual magnetism will affect the judgement of transformer’s differential protection. Upon charging the transformer with no-load, large inrush current will be created with big magnitude and low harmonics, which may lead to the secondary harmonic blocking failure of differential protection. The combined judgement method of secondary harmonics and waveform symmetry will improve the reliability of the differential protection action. An analysis is conducted of the mal-operation of differential protection after the DC resistance testing, and the difference in identifying the inrush current is compared between the blocking criteria of secondary harmonics and waveform symmetry. Based on the analysis, some feasible measures are proposed to avoid the mal- operation of differential protection. At last, with different residual magnetism modeling, the different blocking methods are tested again.

Key words: DC resistance, inrush current, harmonic blocking, waveform symmetry

CLC Number:

TM773

LI Yan-jun, LI Xiao-mei, ZHAO Han. Analysis of a Mal-operation of Differential Protection After the DC Resistance Testing[J]. Electric Power, 2013, 46(2): 55-59.

Add to citation manager EndNote|Ris|BibTeX

URL: https://www.electricpower.com.cn/EN/10.11930/j.issn.1004-9649.2013.2.55.4

https://www.electricpower.com.cn/EN/Y2013/V46/I2/55

References

[1] 马静,吴劫,马磊,等.变压器空载合闸漏感参数识别方法[J].电网技术,2011,35（5）：194-198.
MA Jing, Wu Jie, MA Lei, et al . Recognition of transformer leakage inductance during its no-load closing[J]. Power System Techno1ogy, 2011,35(5):194-198.
[2] 翁汉蜊,林湘宁. 变压器差动保护误动原因的复杂电磁暂态分析[J].中国电机工程学报,2009,29（13）：65-71.
WENG Han-li, LIN Xiang-ning. Analysis of complex electromagnetic transient leading to the mal-operation of power transformer differential protection[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE, 2009,29(13):65-71.
[3] 李立新,束洪春.变压器电压恢复涌流分析[J].电力自动化设备,2007,27（10）：59-63.
LI Li-xin, SHU Hong-chun. Research on recovery inrush in operating transformer[J]. Electric Power Automation Equipment,2007,27(10):59-63.
[4] 郑涛,张婕,高旭. 一起特高压变压器的差动保护误动分析及防范措施[J]. 电力系统自动化,2011,35（18）：92-97.
ZHENG Tao, ZHANG Jie, GAO Xu. Analysis on a mal-operation of differential protection for ultra-high voltage transformer and its countermeasure[J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2011, 35(18):92-97.
[5] 徐树文,李亚楼.应用于三相潮流程序的变压器模型的实现[J].中国电力,2011,44（10）：1-5.
XU Shu-wen, LI Ya-lou. Implementation of transformer models in three-phase load flow program[J]. Electric Power, 2011,44(10):1-5.
[6] 杨建辉,杨建勇,张永祥,等.基于ELDINST仿真的变压器事故分析[J]. 中国电力,2011,44（10）：37-40.
YANG Jian-hui, YANG Jian-yong, ZHANG Yong-xiang, et al .Analyses on transformer accidents based on ELDINST simulation[J]. Electric Power, 2011,44(10):37-40.
[5] 季学军,李哲,姜玉磊,等. 间断角原理微机变压器差动保护的研究与开发[J]. 江苏电机工程,2008,27（6）：5-7.
JI Xue-jun, LI Zhe, JIANG Yu-lei, et al . Research and development of digital transformer diferential relay based on dead angle philosophy[J]. Jiangsu Electrical Engineering, 2008,27(6):5-7.
[6] 李凤荣,马丽英.变压器励磁涌流识别技术的研究趋势和动态[J].电力学报,2010,25（2）：142-145.
LI Feng-rong, MA Li-ying. Research tendency of distinguishing inrush on transformer’s differential protection[J]. Journal of Electric Power, 2010,25(2):142-145.
[7] 潘书燕,郑玉平,吴崇昊,等.变压器新型励磁涌流识别元件[J].电力系统自动化,2011,35（19）：63-67.
PAN Shu-yan, ZHENG Yu-ping, WU Chong-hao, et al . A new identification component for inrush current of power transformer[J]. Automation of Electric Power Systems, 2011,35(19):63-67.
[8] 杨利水,杨旭,徐岩,等. 电力变压器内部故障的非线性仿真模型[J]. 电网技术,2009,33（20）：183-188.
YANG Li-shui, YANG Xu, XU Yan, et al . A nonlinear model to calculate post-internal fault parameters of power transformer[J].Power System Techno1ogy, 2009,33(20):183-188.
[9] 常勇. 500 kV高岭换流站换流变空载充电励磁涌流分析[J]. 电网技术,2009,33（1）：97-100.
CHANG Yong. Analysis on energizing inrush current of no-load converter transformer in 500 kV Gaoling back-to-back converter station[J]. Power System Technology, 2009,33(1):97-100.
[10] 陈达壮,黄家栋,张玲. 基于2种傅氏算法相关性分析的变压器励磁涌流识别方法[J]. 电力自动化设备,2010,30（10）：71-74.
CHEN Da-zhuang, HUANG Jia-dong, ZHANG Ling. Identification of transformer excitation inrush based oil correlation analysis between two Fourier algorithms[J]. Electric Power Automation Equipment, 2010,30(10):71-74.
[11] 谭江平.基于磁通轨迹特征的变压器励磁涌流识别新方法[J].电力自动化设备,2008,28（12）：77-80.
TAN Jiang-pin. Identification of transformer magnetization inrush current based on magnetic flux track[J]. Electric Power Automation Equipment, 2008,28(12):77-80.
[12] 祝磊,丘毅昌,张蓉蓉,等. 基于数学形态谱和LS-SVM的变压器励磁涌流和短路电流识别方法[J].电网技术,2008,32（1）：88-89.
ZHU Lei, QIU Yi-chang, ZHANG Rong-rong, et al . Recognition of inrush current and fault current based on pattern spectrum and LS-SVM[J]. Power System Technology, 2008,32(1):88-89.
[13] 张庆伟,黄宏清,张强,等.利用突变量故障判别法配合模糊谐波分析提高差动保护的性能[J].电网技术,2010,34（8）：205-209.
ZHANG Qing-wei, HUANG Hong-qing, ZHANG Qiang, et al . A method to improve performance of differential protection by combination of abrupt change based fault detection with fuzzy harmonic analysis[J]. Power System Technology, 2010,34(8):205-209.
[14] 文继锋,程骁,张晓宇,等.特高压变压器差动保护研究[J].中国电机工程学报,2009,29（22）：58-62.
WEN Ji-feng, CHENG Xiao, ZHANG Xiao-yu, et al . Study on differential protection of UHV transformer[J]. Proceedings of the CSEE, 2009,29(22):58-62.
[15] 种芝艺,黄杰,文继锋,等.华新换流站500 kV/10 kV站用变保异常动作原因分析及改进方案[J]. 电网技术,2008,32（10）：98-100.
[16] 邵德军,尹项根,张哲,等.改进型二次谐波励磁涌流制动方法[J].电网技术,2006,30（24）：84-88.
SHAO De-jun, YIN Xiang-gen, ZHANG Zhe, et al . Improved second harmonic restrained method for energizing inrush current[J]. Power System Technology, 2006,30(24):84-88.
[17] 陈剑,李炜. 变压器励磁涌流的特性特性分析及应用[J]. 湖南电力,2005,25（4）：4-5,10.
CHEN Jian, LI Wei. Characteristic of transformer magnetizing inrush current and its practical application[J]. Hunan Electric Power, 2005,25(4):4-5,10.